Wednesday, March 5, 2014

Practical Principle of Contradiction

Because an Utterance that sends 'mixed signals', i. e. entails 'Do X and do not do X', is impossible to enact, it is self-defeating qua Communication.  Accordingly, internal coherence is a necessary condition of successful Communication, or, in other words, Communication is governed by a Practical Principle of Contradiction, which, as has been previously discussed, is arguably independent of its more familiar Theoretical counterpart.  Now, the scope of the Principle can be extended beyond a single Utterance, by a single speaker, to all Utterances, by that or all speakers.  So, inconsistencies over time erode not only all the attempts to Communicate by that speaker, but Communication in general.

No comments:

Post a Comment