Monday, November 10, 2014

Ability, Need, Distributive Justice

The formula, 'From each according to his ability, to each according to his need', adopted, not coined, by Marx, can be classified as a principle of Distributive Justice.  Now, since Capitalists rarely engage Marxism on an intellectual level, their objections to that principle can only be a topic of speculation.  One might be that what one receives should be determined by the work that one does, not by what one needs.  However, that argument ignores the first clause of the formula, and, furthermore, is clearly arbitrarily directed, since no Capitalist seems to apply it to the alienation of the fruits of one's labor that is inherent in their own system.  Another objection might be that what one receives should be determined by the Invisible Hand of the Market, a counter the effectiveness of which is plainly dependent on the essentially indemonstrable existence of such an entity.  Indeed, that that version of a Capitalist principle of Distributive Justice is equivalent to a prohibition of third-party interference in commercial exchanges, highlights what is distinctive about its Marxist counterpart--that Distributive Justice is an artefactual process.

No comments:

Post a Comment