Friday, November 9, 2012

Reason, Morality, Lying

Kant's four examples of 'duty' are often regarded as more interesting than rigorously convincing, primarily because of the difficulty in corresponding a logical contradiction with a concrete event.  Still, the example of false promising has been appreciated as more instructive than the others, since it entails both the construction and the breaking of a social convention.  But, that example is distinctive in another respect--it is fundamentally linguistic.  Hence, on that interpretation, false promising is a special case of lying, which is fundamentally immoral, because it undermines the effectiveness of language, the medium of communication, and, hence, it undermines the very basis of social harmony.

No comments:

Post a Comment