Monday, July 26, 2010

Freedom, Nothingness, Nihilism

One of Sartre's better-known statements 'We are condemned to be free', is an overdramatic mischaracterization of his central thesis. There is no 'condemnation' preceding Existence, so the more accurate formulation is simply 'We are free'. Freedom, for Sartre, is the irreducible nature of Existence--each of us is constantly choosing how to be, even whether or not 'to be happy', or 'to be rational', two of the most prominent modes of being that are traditionally characterized as pre-inscribed in human nature. However, one frequently attempts to obscure this absolute Freedom, by recourse to objective conditions as motivations of action, e. g. physical circumstances, a priori essences, divine will, etc. This hiding of one's Freedom, not merely to others, but to oneself, Sartre terms 'Bad Faith'. Now, since this Freedom constitutes Selfhood for Sartre, Bad Faith is a mode of self-denial, which, in Nietzschean terms, is a manifestation of Nihilism. Indeed, even though Sartre himself never addresses the issue, Nietzsche's 'Slave Morality' can be understood as an expression of Bad Faith--it entails the erection of subjective creations, e. g. God, values, as self-subsisting entities to serve as objective grounds of one's actions. So, whereas for Heidegger, 'Nihilism' consists in the forgetting of Being, for Sartre it can be said to consist in the forgetting of Nothingness.

1 comment:

  1. The problem w/Sartre is that he denies any amount of pre-determination of thought. It's a shame that he didn't perform comparative brain anatomy studies, as Freud did. There's a vast differnce between the brain's fine dendritic connection in the top layer of the neo-cortex and the massive myelinated and faster/ more-conductive super-highways crossing the corpus callosum which structurally might account for the tensions between Sartre's pre-reflective and reflective consciousness. If you were to ask me, in order to overcome the myleination process, one must certainly spend a lot of time "purely reflecting"... for that is the only way the neurons will get myelinated and mental "habits" can be overcome.

    Freud, on the other hand, accounted for the "evolutionary" myelination of neural pathways over a persons early/young life leading to thought repression, and so it's not the "static" self-denial manifestation of nihilism of Sartre.

    ReplyDelete