Saturday, August 12, 2017

Skill and Metaphysics

In Bergson's system, the fundamental contrast, if not antithesis, is between dynamic, indivisible, fluidity, and static, divisible, solidity.  Exemplifications of that contrast that he offers include Duration-Space, Spirit-Matter, and Metaphysics-Physics.  But, also exemplifying it are Water-Earth, and skilled activity-unskilled activity.  Now, as has been previously discussed, Skill transcends Newtonian Determinism, so the alignment of such a process with 'Metaphysics' is not inappropriate.  However, Water is Material, so Bergson's association of indivisible fluidity with Spirit, a concept long associated with immateriality, reflects an hostility to corporeality.  So, while his privileging of the first set of characteristics inverts the orientation of a long tradition, he compromises his otherwise Naturalistic innovation with some unnecessary mystification, if not prejudice.

No comments:

Post a Comment