Wednesday, October 12, 2016

Anarchism and Orchestra

An orchestra is an example of a multiplicity that functions effectively, not only collectively, but individually, as well, under the direction of a unitary leader.  Thus, there is no a priori reason why, as Proudhon implicitly believes, a hierarchy necessarily adversely constrains an individual member of a society.  So, the value of Anarchism is contingent on circumstances, e. g. it might vitalize a hitherto sclerotic hierarchical society, but it might accelerate the de-vitalization of one that is already decaying.  That there are music collectives, e. g.  jazz combos, that perform effectively  without a conductor, and, hence, exemplify Anarchism, does not contradict the possibility of a healthy society in which ruler and ruled are distinguished, i. e. as a conductor and player are.

No comments:

Post a Comment