Saturday, August 23, 2014

Democracy and Empiricism

Smith's "invisible hand", even if interpreted as a heuristic device, as he likely intends, not as an actual entity, as some of his self-styled followers presume, introduces a factor of Justice into his system of profit-seeking.  Mill's 'general good', and his distinction between 'higher' and 'lower' pleasure, introduce objective normative principles into Bentham's Psychological Egoism.  Each variation by these prominent Political Empiricists implicitly acknowledges a significant shortcoming of that doctrine--that wish-expression does not suffice as a foundation of a Poltical Philosophy.  Thus, insofar as the essence of Democracy is such wish-expression, i. e. electoral processes, it shares that weakness.  Now, while Smith's device may itself be no more than another example of wishful thinking, Mill's measures suggest how Democracy can be salvaged--via Education that re-directs conduct beyond immediate data, i. e. towards more comprehensive personal or collective ends.  But, whether or not such cultivation can be based strictly on Empiricist premises is unclear.

No comments:

Post a Comment