Wednesday, December 26, 2012

Spirit, Sense-Object, Expulse, Communication

If, as Kant conceives it, Spirit is an "animating principle", then the first moment of a 'phenomenology' of Spirit is not a sense-object, as it is for Hegel, but what can be called an 'expulse', which connotes better than 'impulse' that Animation generates manifest motion.  However, the difference between Expulse and Sense-Object  is no mere expression of a difference of interpretation of one and the same datum.  Rather, it entails a correction of a fundamental falsification of immediate Experience that Hegel, following Descartes and Hume, repeats.  For, what is self-evidently given in each of those projects is not some private element, but a process of writing.  Accordingly, the first moment in such a phenomenology is an Expulse to Communicate.  Now, because he conceives Spirit as a trans-personal principle, Hegel can accept, more easily than his predecessors can, as the foundation of Experience, an event in which the existence of a plurality of subjects is implied.  However, because he also conceives Spirit as a principle of Knowledge, and not of Action, he cannot recognize that event as essentially an act of communication, initiated by an expulse.  He, thus, inverts Kant's concept of Spirit.

No comments:

Post a Comment