The modeling of Utilitarianism on Smith's system is based on the correlations of Pleasure with Profit, and Pain with Loss. Now, the latter of each pair connotes a net quantity, i. e. an increase or decrease with respect to a prior condition. But, beginning with Locke, a sense-datum, such as Pleasure or Pain, is a presupposition-less event. Therefore, because Utilitarianism is an Empiricist doctrine, Bentham's and Mill's attempts to apply Empiricism to Smith's system are structurally flawed, at minimum.
No comments:
Post a Comment